As far as I can tell this basically means that all apps must be approved by Apple to follow their “platform policies for security and privacy” even if publishing on a third party app store. They will also disable updating apps from third party app stores if you stay outside the EU for too long (even if you are a citizen of an EU country, with an Apple account set to the EU region).

The idea that preventing app updates is in line with their claims of protecting security is utterly absurd. “Never attibute to malice what can be explained with stupidity,” but Apple isn’t stupid.

  • Jramskov
    20·
    7 months ago

    I’m generally ok with them requiring basic security and privacy protections through the notarization.

    • ferralcat
      210·
      7 months ago

      Signing doesn’t provide security of privacy protections. It just means you paid apple a fee.

    • shrugal
      100·
      7 months ago

      They can ask users if they want that, I’m sure many of their users do. What they shouldn’t do is force people to accept their version of “security and privacy”.

      • jarfil
        10·
        7 months ago

        They don’t force anyone; plenty of non-Apple devices out there to choose from.

        • shrugal
          70·
          7 months ago

          It gets a bit more complicated than that when it comes to antitrust law.

          • jarfil
            10·
            7 months ago7 months ago

            Apple has less than 30% mobile maket share in the EU, antitrust laws usually kick in above 66%, and very rarely above 50%.

            There are other laws being worked on to combat shrinkflation, and others to curb all the tricks of removing features after the sale, but they’re not here yet, and it remains to be seen whether they’d apply.

            • Jramskov
              30·
              7 months ago

              I don’t think that’s how to look at it. There’s clearly something less than optimal about having these huge gatekeepers (as I believe is the term used) and the EU is trying to limit their power.

              • jarfil
                10·
                7 months ago7 months ago

                Gatekeepers and the DMA, are not exactly antitrust laws; they are a series of regulations applied to entities providing a digital service to above roughly 10% of the EU population, no matter the market share, without provisions to break them up.

                I guess… you could call them “antitrust light”, sort of.

    • Knuschberkeks
      100·
      7 months ago

      yes but I want the option to judge software myself. If I want software that has been looked over by Apple I can go to the Apple Appstore. If I want something that doesn’t fit their requirements I want the option to go somewhere else.