What are some of your favorite communities that feature topics like literature, science, ecology, aerospace, technology, politics, history, arts, culture, theory, and debate?

Where do responsible, respectful adults go for discussions and for substantive, high quality posts and comments by decent human beings?

(Not just limited to academic/intellectual topics, could be anything from hobbies to defense contracts to careers to skills. Just looking for respectful, reasonably intelligent, informed, relatively engaged communities.)

Also, are forum aggregators like Lemmy and Reddit even the best places to find such communities outside of listservers, universities, and academic conferences?

  • breadsmasherEnglish
    880·
    7 months ago

    Where do responsible, respectful adults go for discussions and for substantive, high quality posts and comments by decent human beings?

    I don’t think you will find this Utopia online

    • andrewEnglish
      281·
      7 months ago7 months ago

      That’s been my experience for 95% of Lemmy communities right now, though. I don’t know if it will last but for now, it seems pretty high quality.

      • the post of tom joad
        90·
        7 months ago7 months ago

        Yeah i feel like this is how the early redditors must’ve felt. I don’t want this to get huge frankly

        • Shyfer
          71·
          7 months ago

          It was. But there were interesting effects from Reddit getting huge, like more niche subreddits and random encounters, like someone posting a proposal pictures and the targets of it being able to find it online. That probably wouldn’t happen on Lemmy.

          Probably a worthy trade for better discussion and less bots, though.

    • Jordan117English
      151·
      7 months ago

      I thoroughly enjoy MetaFilter (one of the last surviving community blogs from the 90s) and Tildes (a more recent attempt at capturing the same feel). Text-heavy discourse, minimalist design, human-scale moderation, and moderately gatekept (MeFi has a $5 fee, Tildes is invite-only). PM me if you’re interested.

    • dan
      111·
      7 months ago

      This is what small forums with good moderators used to be, back in “the old days”. Modern forums (and Lemmy) just don’t have quite the same feel any more.

    • bedwyrOP
      80·
      7 months ago

      There used to be a website called WiserEarth (and then later Wiser.org). This was an internet utopia for intellectual, empathetic discussion about sociopolitical, environmental, ecological, and economic discussion. Really miss that community. But yeah, few. And far between.